Stamp duty overhaul may not be enough

By Vivienne Kelly

A recent survey of lenders and mortgage brokers revealed many of them would like to see stamp duty removed or reduced in order to stimulate the housing market, but others contend the measure would simply be a Band-Aid solution.

The Genworth Home Grown Report surveyed over 300 mortgage brokers and lenders and asked: ‘If state or federal government could make one change to benefit the mortgage industry over the next five years, what would it be?’

Over 40 per cent of lenders and 30 per cent of mortgage brokers said the removal or reduction of stamp duties would be the most effective measure – well ahead of the next most popular choice ‘reinstate/increase incentives for FHBs [first home buyers]’, which 11 per cent of lenders and 17 per cent of brokers selected.

Speaking at Genworth’s launch of the report this morning, however, panellists agreed that stamp duty concessions would not address the raft of issues facing first home buyers and investors who are priced out of various capital city markets.

James Hickey, financial services partner at Deloitte, said that if stamp duties were removed or reduced, state governments would scramble to acquire the revenue from other sources.

He said this revenue was vital for undertaking infrastructure projects, which encourage people to live in certain areas.

Mr Hickey suggested introducing land taxes may be a more equitable way to reduce pressure on people who are buying, but still enable governments to maintain their revenue.

John Symond, executive chairman of Aussie, said the stamp duties are a small part of the problem.

“There’s no silver bullet here. It’s a very complex problem,” he said. “Stamp duty, to cut or give concessions further, it’s just a Band-Aid job. Government grants are just a Band-Aid job. We’re not addressing the fundamental problems of why we’re having housing affordability issues.”

Thank you.

Your enquiry has been sent to a local Aussie Mortgage Broker.

We will be in contact with you shortly.

error occurred.
Unfortunately Aussie cannot attend to your home loan related enquiry at this stage as you must be a citizen or permanent resident.
Do you need help finding the right loan for your investment?
What Aussie do for you:
  • Give expert mortgage advice to help you find great investment loan deals
  • Help you maximise return by lowering financing costs
  • Save you time and effort by helping with the paperwork
First name
Last name
Mobile Number
Are you an Australian Resident?
promoted stories

Top Suburbs

Highest annual price growth - click a suburb below to view full profile data:
BLUE BAY 49.18%
Stamp duty overhaul may not be enough
SPI logo