PART 2 • KNOW WHAT YOU’RE BUYING
Know what you’re buying: Assets and asset selection
CHAPTER 01
Introduction
In Part 1 of this series, the question was whether commercial property belongs in an investor’s portfolio at all. Part 2 turns to the next question: if it does, what exactly should you buy?
The answer is harder than it sounds. In residential property, the choices are relatively linear: capital growth or rental yields, houses or units, regional or metropolitan. Commercial property is not one asset class balanced against a location. It is a dozen or more, each with its own tenants, buildings, economics, and risks, and each reflecting a different part of how Australians make their living.
This report, the second of a six-part series, draws on the conversation between Phil Tarrant and Right Property Group founder Victor Kumar. It maps the commercial property universe, sets out the three tests Victor applies to any asset, and compares how the major sectors behave. It also looks at which sectors face structural change, and what investors should do when a once-desirable building starts to age out of relevance.
“In residential we talk about a house, a townhouse, a unit. In commercial it’s a dozen different asset classes, each with its own economics.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CHAPTER 02
The commercial property universe
At its simplest, commercial property is grouped into three core categories: retail, office, and industrial. Beneath those sits a long list of sub-sectors. Phil and Victor work through many of them:
| CATEGORY | WHAT IT COVERS |
|---|---|
| Retail | Shops and showrooms, from quick-service restaurants to local strips |
| Neighbourhood retail | Suburban strips with a mix of food outlets, services, and convenience tenants |
| Large-format retail | Big-box tenants such as furniture and appliance retailers |
| Office | Class A, B, and C buildings, from CBD towers to business-park suites |
| Industrial | Warehouses and units, from small industrial to specialised facilities |
| Warehouses and logistics | Larger distribution assets, usually a subset of industrial |
| Specialised industrial | Assets such as cold storage or machining facilities |
| Medical and healthcare | Doctors’ surgeries, physiotherapy, and allied health premises |
| Childcare | Purpose-built centres leased to operators |
| Service stations | Fuel outlets, often with a convenience store attached |
| Hospitality | Pubs, bars, and restaurants |
| Storage | Self-storage and storage units |
| Mixed use, strata commercial, freestanding, and regional commercial | Assets defined by how they are held, where they are, or how they are used |
| Other specialised or emerging types | Assets that serve niche or newly developing needs |
The list matters because every line on it has its own economic engine. How a childcare operator makes money has little in common with how a warehouse tenant does. The investor is not simply buying a building. They are buying exposure to an industry, and each industry rises and falls on different forces.
That is also why a conversation about “commercial property” in general is rarely useful. The sensible question is which type, with which tenant, on which lease, in which location.
CHAPTER 03
3 tests every commercial asset must pass
Victor’s starting point for comparing such different assets is a simple framework. Any asset class, he says, needs to pass three tests.
THREE TESTS
01
Re-leasability
02
Obsolescence
03
Capital expenditure drag
1. Re-leasability. “If the tenant left tomorrow, how easy is it to rent out again without a new fit-out?” The test is whether another business could step in quickly, and at what cost.
2. Obsolescence. Will the building still do the same job in 15 years? Technology, consumer habits, and regulation can all change whether a building and fit-out will attract new tenancies.
3. Capital expenditure drag. Who pays when the roof needs replacing, or the air-conditioning fails? The answer varies by lease, by tenure and by asset type, and it can quietly erode returns.
“If the tenant left tomorrow, how easy is it to rent out again without a new fit-out? Is there going to be another business ready to step in?”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
The three tests complement the valuation pillars from Part 1. The tenant, lease, industry, and building determine what an asset is worth today. The three tests determine how that value holds up when something goes wrong.
CHAPTER 04
Generic versus specialised: The re-leasing divide
The most important distinction in asset selection may be between generic and specialised property. A generic asset is one where almost any business can move in without changing the fit-out. A specialised asset is built or fitted for one type of use.
Industrial warehouses are the clearest example of generic property. Victor describes them as perhaps the easiest and most predictable on the re-leasing test: essentially walls, a roller door, and a clear floor. Give it a clean, and the next tenant can start. An office suite can also be generic if it is in good order. A warehouse fitted out with hoists for a mechanic is less so.
At the other end are medical centres, childcare centres, and quick-service restaurants such as a KFC. These often come with longer leases, which looks like a strength. But Victor argues there is a price for that security.
“You’re now dealing with perhaps five replacement tenants in there as opposed to 100 replacement tenants in the industrial side,” he says. When the tenant leaves, the property takes longer to re-let. “You’re going to pay in the end,” he says, “because when you have a turnover of tenant, it takes longer.”
INDUSTRIAL
“100 replacement tenants”
Walls, a roller door, and a clear floor
SPECIALISED
“Perhaps five replacement tenants”
Medical centres, childcare centres, quick-service restaurants
That lag is the hidden cost of specialisation. A long lease on a narrow-use building defers the risk. It does not remove it.
Re-leasing risk, asset by asset
Phil asks Victor to rate re-leasing risk across the sectors. His answers, with the qualifications attached, are as follows:
SECTOR
RE-LEASING RISK
Warehouses and logistics
Easier at smaller sizes. Larger logistics assets carry medium-to-high risk and are usually out of reach for most investors.
Medical and healthcare
Location and fit-out matter, and so does the age of the practice. A surgery that opened a year ago does not yet have a client base. An ageing population supports demand, but Victor leans towards medium-to-high risk where the asset is not right.
Childcare
Investors need to know the competitors within a two-kilometre radius, how many new developments are opening nearby, and whether the centre is positioned as a feeder to a school.
Service stations
location-specific
Contamination, freeway bypasses, and the slow shift towards electric vehicles all weigh on the outlook. Victor’s preference is a station attached to a convenience store.
Hospitality
Car parking, road access, and the mix of businesses decide whether one strip thrives while another struggles.
Neighbourhood retail
A long-established restaurant is low risk. A newly opened high-end venue is high risk.
Large-format retail
Leases tend to be longer, and the investor generally knows well ahead of time if a tenant is leaving.
Storage
Demand is steady, and replacement tenants are plentiful.
The ratings are Victor’s judgements rather than industry benchmarks, but the logic behind them is consistent: the narrower the pool of replacement tenants, the higher the re-leasing risk.
CHAPTER 05
What drives demand, and who occupies the building
Demand for each category comes from a different source, and it pays to understand it before comparing yields.
Retail: Location, type, and online resilience
Victor says retail demand depends on the location and the type of retailer. The quick-service chains such as McDonald’s and KFC are a different proposition from the kebab shop down the road. They typically have longer leases, so investors accept a lower yield for the perceived safety.
Those blue-chip sites are often out of reach. Because replacements for a fast-food tenant are limited, lenders may offer loan-to-value ratios of only 50 to 60 per cent. Victor says buyers may need $3 million to $5 million in deposit capital. In practice, this is the territory of sophisticated investors and family offices.
For everything else, the key question is how resilient the business is to hard times and to online competition. Victor argues that retail that sells services is safer than retail that sells goods. You cannot buy a haircut online. But even then, local competition and trading hours matter, and he recommends visiting the premises at different times of day to gauge foot traffic.
Phil says that the services-and-wellness side of retail is likely to prove more resistant to AI and online disruption, and expects more retail assets to pivot towards it.
CASE STUDY 1
The disappearing $2 shop, and the rise of the dog groomer
Retail demand changes faster than most investors expect.
THE DEAL
Victor points to western Sydney, where $2 shops were common a decade ago and are now hard to find, while dog groomers have boomed. He notes that one large chain of such shops, mostly located in major regional areas of NSW and Victoria, is now selling down a lot of its assets.
THE LESSON
Tenant categories rise and fall with consumer behaviour. Before buying, ask whether the business would still be fit for purpose in 15 years, and whether the buyer could simply get the same thing online. When a sector’s own landlords start selling, take notice.
Office: Building class, location, and the incentive gap
Victor says office demand has to be viewed through two lenses: building class and location. Class A buildings have good fit-outs, quality lobbies, and strong energy ratings. Class B buildings were once Class A but are now dated. Class C is the most basic: the lift is creaky, there is no lobby presence, and the tenants are often start-ups watching cash flow. The vacancy rate nationally, when Victor last checked, was 16.4 per cent for office, against 4.8 per cent for industrial.
16.4%
National office vacancy, when Victor last checked
4.8%
National industrial vacancy
Vacancy is not evenly spread. Victor says B and C class buildings carry more vacancy than Class A at this point in the cycle. In Sydney, Parramatta has new, high-quality buildings but still has high vacancy, and some businesses are moving into the CBD, where space is more available and per-square-metre rates are lower than in Parramatta. North-west Sydney, he says, is the most expensive office market per square metre.
Office is also the sector where incentives distort the picture. Face rents and effective rents can be very different, and buyers who rely on the headline number are not working with the true rate.
FROM THE SOURCE
The most expensive office market, and the one that rarely sits empty
NORTH-WEST SYDNEY
Most expensive
office market in the city per square metre
CBD
Around 40% less rent
Victor’s estimate if RPG’s office moved there
SINCE 2009
Usually no vacancies
in the north-west business park
Victor’s own office shows how location and cost can pull in different directions. He says north-west Sydney is the most expensive office market in the city per square metre. If he relocated Right Property Group’s office into the CBD, he estimates he would pay around 40 per cent less.
Parramatta tells the other side of the story. Years ago it was not a place for offices, but it now has a lot of new Class A buildings. Vacancy there is still quite high, and some businesses are moving into the CBD, where space is more available, and the rate per square metre is cheaper than in Parramatta. Parramatta, in turn, is cheaper than the north-west.
Yet Victor has been in his north-west business park since 2009, and says prolonged vacancies are not something he sees there. There is one vacant office on his floor now. He credits connectivity, including the metro, re-leasability, and building classification.
The lesson: A newer building is not enough, and a high rent does not mean weak demand. Check vacancy, connectivity, and how quickly space re-lets, not just the age of the stock or the rate per square metre.
CASE STUDY 2
The office lease that didn’t mean what it said
Victor’s own experience as a tenant shows how incentives can hide the real rent.
THE DEAL
Right Property Group has been based in a north-west Sydney business park since 2009. When Victor negotiated the lease for the office, it included a discount for paying on time, which he says he always does, and, from memory, six months rent-free. The headline per-square-metre rate in the lease was much higher than what he actually pays.
THE LESSON
Anyone buying an office on face rent alone is not working from the true per-square-metre figure. Incentives can be large and opaque. Look for what was promised, what has been paid and what remains owing.
Victor notes that many accountants and financial planners buy their own office space, often through a self-managed super fund and rent it back to their own business. That can make sense, he says, but only if the building is right.
Industrial: The least and most volatile
Victor describes industrial as potentially the least volatile sector for the average investor, and also the most volatile in a downturn. The explanation is that industrial tenants may be the first to fold when the economy weakens, but replacements can step in quickly. The gap between tenants is usually short, provided the location is sound.
He pointed to South-East Queensland, where industrial property outperformed residential on growth between 2017 and 2019. The assets that did best had good connectivity to the freeway, nearby amenities and a good mix of tenants.
Smaller industrial assets tend to carry lower yields because they are popular, and the rents are in the tens of thousands of dollars rather than the hundreds of thousands. That makes them accessible to a wider range of investors. Victor recommends looking at site coverage: is the whole site used, and is there still value to add? A varied mix of tenants in an industrial complex tends to be safer than one skewed heavily towards a single trade. He has seen complexes in which around half the tenants were mechanics.
Industrial rents are also relatively easy to benchmark. Most units in a complex are similar, so rent per square metre can be compared directly within the same complex.
Medical, childcare, and hospitality: The operator is the investment
In these sectors, Victor says, the first thing the investor is actually buying is the business longevity and lease. What you’re buying least is the building.
“The first thing we’re actually investing in is the actual business. Then we’re investing in the lease, then we’re investing in the sector. And finally, the building.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
This order of priorities reflects how sector selection should work. First decide which businesses you are comfortable with. Healthcare, for instance, may suit an investor who wants stability. An investor comfortable with a little vacancy may prefer industrial. Only then does the building come into focus.
CASE STUDY 3
The pharmacy with no neighbours
Some retail is more defensive than it looks.
THE DEAL
Right Property Group acquired a pharmacy in Adelaide that had been trading for 20 years. It sits on its own block, with no other pharmacies within three kilometres.
THE LESSON
The same type of tenant can be low or high risk depending on competition. A pharmacy with three or four rivals nearby would be a very different investment. Retail is not a single risk category. The question is whether the business can be easily replaced, or easily competed away.
CASE STUDY 4
2 restaurants, side by side
Hospitality shows how much longevity matters.
THE DEAL
Near where Victor lives, a Thai restaurant has operated from the same premises, with the same menu, since 1997. Next door, an Italian restaurant opened, changed hands four times, and sat vacant at various points in between.
THE LESSON
In hospitality, track record is the best indicator of a tenant’s staying power. A restaurant that has traded for decades is a very different proposition from a new venue with a similar address.
Storage: Simple on paper, less so in practice
Storage is increasingly accessible to investors, and Victor rates its re-leasing risk as very low. He is developing 47 storage units in the Snowy Mountains, where demand is linked to the Snowy Hydro works. The land was previously a residential lot and is being rezoned by his development partner. The units are essentially a large shed with partitions, and he describes the project as demand-led, with interest from prospective tenants already in hand.
Both Phil and Victor sound a note of caution. Phil says he is nervous about promoters pitching storage as an easy entry to commercial property, because for many people it may be the only commercial asset they can afford. Victor added that investors must decide whether they are owning the space or running the business. They are two very different things.
FROM THE SOURCE
Building storage where the demand already exists
Victor’s own storage project shows what the low-risk version of the sector looks like. He is developing 47 storage units in the Snowy Mountains, a precinct driven by demand linked to the Snowy Hydro works, where workers and contractors need somewhere to keep equipment and belongings.
The units are, as he puts it, just boxes: a large tin shed with partitions. The land was a residential lot and is being rezoned by his development partner, a process he is quick to say was not his own work and is not simple. Crucially, there is already interest from prospective tenants, which is why he rates it low risk.
“This is pretty much demand-led,” Victor says. “We’ve already got people interested.”
The lesson: Storage is only low risk where the demand is real. Building for an identified customer base is a very different proposition from buying cheap storage because it is all you can afford.
Specialised industrial and regional assets
On cold storage, Victor says location matters as much as the asset. Re-leasing is generally better in a major regional area, where demand is strong, but the investor should look closely at what kind of cold storage it is.
He uses it to illustrate the difference between yield and risk. An investor looking at a regional cold storage property at an 8 per cent yield should ask why the owner is selling. Often, he says, the seller is de-risking, perhaps because only five years remain on the lease. Having possibly bought at a 10 or 12 per cent yield, the vendor is exiting at 8 per cent, which represents a large capital gain. The buyer then inherits the re-leasing risk.
“If it’s paying 8 per cent, why are they selling? They’re trying to de-risk their portfolio.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CHAPTER 06
What determines rent and value
For all these assets, rent is the engine of cash flow, and Victor argues the certainty of rent should be the biggest driver of asset selection.
Three factors shape it. The first is whether the asset is generic or specialised, since that sets the rent per square metre and the yield. The second is the sector’s economics. The third is the lease itself: its length, options, incentives, and the outgoings it recovers. As Part 1 explained, value then follows from the net income and the yield the market demands.
NET INCOME
÷
YIELD
=
CAPITAL VALUE
The pattern across sectors is consistent. More generic assets with deep pools of replacement tenants, such as industrial units, tend to trade on lower yields. Riskier or narrower assets, such as a lease on a specialised building nearing expiry, may offer higher yields as compensation. The yield is the market’s price for risk, not a bonus.
CHAPTER 07
Capital expenditure: Treat every asset as if it were strata
The third test, capital expenditure drag, deserves its own treatment, because it catches many investors out.
Victor’s advice is to read the lease closely when an agent says all outgoings are paid by the tenant. Capital items such as roof replacement, major plant or structural works can usually not be passed on, even where operating costs can.
CASE STUDY 5
The $500k air-conditioning bill
Capital works can arrive without warning, and the cost lands on the owner.
THE DEAL
Victor owns an asset in a strata complex on St Kilda Road in Melbourne. The air-conditioning failed, and replacing it and re-channelling it to each strata space was quoted at $500,000. Each owner had to contribute $30,000.
THE LESSON
Such capital expenditure generally cannot be passed on to tenants. Strata levies for the administration fund can often be recovered, but the capital works fund component usually cannot. Read the lease to see what is actually being passed on.
Victor’s takeaway applies well beyond strata. Investors in freehold property should treat every asset as if it were strata. That means setting aside their own capital fund, because at some point major spending will be required. Phil agreed: a freehold owner needs to think the same way. Victor draws the same parallel with residential, noting that in a Queensland property he owns, patch repairs eventually gave way to a full roof replacement.
“You need to pretend that every asset that you own is actually strata, and you create your own capital fund of having that money squirrelled away. Because at some point in time you will need to spend money on this.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CHAPTER 08
Which sectors are under pressure?
Post-budget, Victor says, investors should be most careful with retail that would not survive an economic downturn. Beyond that, he identified three sectors where he sees structural change underway.
CBD offices. With hybrid work now the norm and many staff in the office only two or three days a week, tenants want a good environment when they do come in. Victor says only Class A offices are really worth considering.
Childcare. The economics depend heavily on government policy, including how operators are paid and the staff-to-child ratios. Phil noted that a change in ratios or rebates can change a centre’s economics immediately. Investors also need to watch local supply.
NDIS-related buildings. Victor warns of oversupply and of significant changes coming to the payment model. The scheme is over budget, which means cutbacks are likely, and those could affect rentability and cash flow. He says investors might prefer properties for more robust participants, rather than those requiring high levels of physical support.
Technology is the wider force running through all of this. Phil observed that technological change, as seen in recent weeks with AI, is something governments cannot control, and that it will be a recurring theme in asset selection. The question for every asset is how dependent it is on the kind of work, or the kind of shopping, that technology is changing.
CHAPTER 09
When yesterday’s prized building becomes tomorrow’s obsolete asset
The discussion ended with a hard question. What happens when a building that was highly desirable when you bought it becomes one that no one wants? You have collected the rent and perhaps enjoyed some capital growth, but you are now left holding an asset the market has moved on from.
Victor’s answer is active management. “What you start out with may not be what you end up with,” he says, and the same is true in residential, where units that suited an area one decade may fall out of favour the next. He recommends reviewing every asset every two to three years to ask:
- Is the premises becoming obsolete for this tenant’s business?
- Is the industry itself changing?
- Is the tenant outgrowing the space?
That last question can be an opportunity. If a growing tenant needs more room, the landlord can create it, which tends to produce a stickier tenant who is more likely to stay.
Phil sums up the principle: a property manager manages the property, but the owner has to manage the investment, including how it fits into the wider portfolio.
The portfolio is also the backstop. If an industry changes and a building needs to be repurposed, the investor may need significant capital, and a vacant property is harder to borrow against. Victor notes that a residential property may be there to support that moment, whether by selling down or by drawing on its equity. He also revisited the idea of “pigeon pairing”, where two properties, one growth-oriented and one cash-flow-oriented, are viewed as a single self-sustaining group. He argues that pairing residential with commercial is even more relevant, because the commercial asset has a much higher chance of reaching positive cash flow.
CHAPTER 10
Capital decides what you can buy, and the maths decides what you should
Asset selection is constrained by capital. Victor says a lot of it comes down to how much the investor has, since that determines which assets are within reach and what loan-to-value ratios will apply. Medical centres are an example. A property with a 10-year lease remaining and options may attract a loan-to-value ratio of 70 to 80 per cent on a low-doc basis, according to Victor, though he cautions that different brokers will tell investors different things. He recommends a specialist commercial broker, in the same way that a broker who only deals with first home buyers is different from one who handles investors with several properties.
Once the investor has a shortlist, the final step is to map the numbers.
FROM THE SOURCE
The $2m asset that turns cash-neutral in year 4
PURCHASE COST
About 105%
of the negotiated price
YEAR 1
–$20k
annual loss on a $2m asset (hypothetical)
YEAR 4
Cash neutral
if the lease rises 4% a year and rates hold
Victor says buyers should remember that a purchase effectively costs about 105 per cent of the negotiated price, once stamp duty, solicitor fees and other costs are included. He then walked through a hypothetical: a $2 million asset that runs at a $20,000 annual loss in year one. If the lease rises by 4 per cent a year, and interest rates do not move, the shortfall narrows each year and might reach cash neutral by year four. After that it begins to move into positive territory, and debt can be paid down faster. That process can be accelerated by selling down residential assets, if that is part of the plan.
Victor says this timeline, including a vacancy allowance for the area and asset type, should be mapped with a financial planner. Doing so can also help decide which asset is right: the industrial warehouse or the medical centre, for instance.
“Investing in residential is all about sentiment. It’s all about comparable growth. Investing in commercial is all about mathematics.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CHAPTER 11
Investor checklist: Choosing the right asset
Before committing to a particular commercial asset, consider: (Tick each one you can answer with confidence.)
0 of 11
Anything unticked is worth working through before you buy. That’s a useful answer too.
And finally: are you choosing this asset because it passes the tests, or because it is the one you could afford?