PART 3 • WHERE COMMERCIAL PROPERTY GOES WRONG
Where commercial property goes wrong: Understanding and managing risk
CHAPTER 01
Introduction
Risk is a constant, unchanging factor in commercial property investing, though many new investors chasing yields overlook how this can change the value and profitability of your portfolio. The general consensus is that a commercial property is a riskier investment than residential, and the reasons are not hard to find: longer vacancies, more complex leases, tenants that are businesses rather than households, and far fewer landlord protections.
With more investors turning to commercial property, the timing of this report matters. As Phil Tarrant notes at the start of the third episode, the post-budget landscape has shifted quickly: negative gearing ends from the start of the next financial year, capital gains tax rules have changed, and borrowing for residential property inside a self-managed super fund is no longer allowed. Those changes may push more investors towards commercial property, but they don’t make it safer.
This report, the third of a six-part series, draws on the conversation between Phil and Right Property Group founder Victor Kumar. It works through six categories of risk: vacancy, tenant, lease, economic, structural and property-specific. It also looks at how to decide when a risk is simply too big to take.
SIX CATEGORIES OF RISK
01
Vacancy
02
Tenant
03
Lease
04
Economic
05
Structural
06
Property-specific
Victor is careful to say that the aim is not to scare investors off. “We’ve painted a fairly bleak picture,” he says, “because we’re trying to highlight that there is a lot more diligence that needs to happen.”
“Yield is what you’re paying for carrying the risk. It is your job as the investor to work out whether you’re being paid enough to carry it.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CHAPTER 02
Yield is the price of risk, and you are the one carrying it
Part 1 made the point that a high yield is not a bargain by default. Victor returns to it as the organising idea for this discussion. An 8 per cent yield means the investor is carrying more risk than with a 6 per cent yield property, and the question is whether the extra return is enough to compensate for that risk.
Phil adds a reminder that most commercial investors want two things at once: income now and value growth over time. A property that generates cash but does not grow in value is hard to sell to the next buyer. Victor agrees that the investor needs to decide which matters more at this stage of their journey, cash flow or growth, because that decides which assets and which risks make sense.
CHAPTER 03
Vacancy risk: Months, not weeks
The most obvious risk is also the most expensive. A residential vacancy is typically a couple of weeks, depending on the location and the cycle. It is also easy to adjust, with residential landlords able to slightly reduce rent to spur interest, with sometimes minimal impact on the yield. In commercial property, Victor says, vacancies can run from a couple of months to a couple of years.
How long depends on the sector and the market. Victor points to national vacancy of about 4.8 percent for industrial against around 16 percent for office, which he describes as roughly four times the risk. That risk comes with a trade-off. Office is cheaper to buy and typical net yields are 6, 7 or 8 per cent, against 4 or 5 per cent for industrial. The investor has to decide whether the yield justifies the exposure to another COVID-19-type event or to the continuing shift to working from home.
About 4.8%
National industrial vacancy
Around 16%
National office vacancy: roughly four times the risk
Office also demands more capital than many assume. Victor says purchase prices usually start at $2 million or more, and an investor might need about $600,000 for a lease doc loan, rising to $700,000 or $800,000 if the lender applies a higher risk rating. Industrial, he says, is now where office was before COVID-19. The economics have changed demand, and with it what is in vogue.
Phil adds that commercial vacancy is harder to fix and can require more costly maintenance. In a residential tenancy you can drop the rent for six months to attract someone and raise it later. Inside a commercial lease, that flexibility is much more limited, and reducing the rent comes at a cost of devaluing the asset. The practical answer, they agree, is a buffer. Part 1 puts the figure at six to 12 months of operating costs.
Adjust the yield for the empty months
Victor’s “puritan” approach is to correct the headline yield for vacancy. If a property is advertised at a 6.5 per cent net yield, the investor should ask what the yield really is once the normal vacancy for that asset type, area and industry is taken into account. In his example, it might be nearer 6.1 per cent. If the plan is to hold for 10 years, those predictable income gaps have to be built into the numbers from the start.
6.5%
Advertised net yield
Nearer 6.1%
Once the normal vacancy is taken into account
“You need to look at all of the moving parts and the income gaps, the predictable income gaps, that you would have whilst owning this property.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CASE STUDY 1
The 20% yield with no way out
Some of the highest yields in commercial property reflect the narrowest range of replacement tenants.
THE DEAL
Victor points to hotels and motels as an example of specialised assets where yields can reach as high as 20 per cent, depending on what is on offer. If the operator goes bust, however, the owner is left with a string of rooms with no residential overlay, and it is very hard to find residential tenants to fill them.
THE LESSON
A yield that high is the market’s way of pricing a long, hard vacancy. Victor’s rule of thumb is that the more specialised the tenant, the more the yield has to compensate for two or three years of empty space.
CHAPTER 04
Tenant risk: Who is actually paying the rent?
The tenant is central to value and to cash flow, and Victor’s advice is consistent: invest in the tenant before you invest in the lease. A specialised tenant who goes bust can leave an asset empty for two or three years.
Process: Control the deal, then do the deep dive
Victor describes a deliberate order of operations. Once a price is agreed, the first step is to get the property under contract so the investor controls the asset. Before spending any money on pest and building inspections, the next step is a deep dive into the lease and the tenant.
Some tenants are comfortable sharing their financials, but most are not, so there is a lot of interviewing to be done. That includes peripheral research such as talking to the tenant next door. For retail, it means visiting the premises to see whether the foot traffic is real or whether the business is on the way to becoming a derelict shopfront. Phil notes that there is a balance: investigate enough to be confident, but not so much that the tenant decides you are a headache.
Guarantees: How easily can you get to the money?
Personal and corporate guarantees give comfort, but not all are equal. Victor’s question is how easy it would be to reach the money if the tenant failed.
- A director’s guarantee with no real money behind it is the weakest form.
- Cash held in a trust account is accessible.
- A bank guarantee means the bank is holding the funds. For example, $100,000 sitting in an account and guaranteed by the bank.
- A charge over a director’s assets can be hard to get to.
“If they went bust, how easy will it be to get to the money? And cash is king at the end of the day.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
National names are not a guarantee
CASE STUDY 2
The national tenant that went belly up
Big names can create a false sense of security.
THE DEAL
Victor recalls ABC Learning, the childcare operator that was a national tenant and ASX-listed. When the business failed, a large number of centres had to close.
THE LESSON
A large tenant is not automatically a safe one. Look at how quickly the business is expanding. If it is a franchise, check whether the lease is held by the franchisor or by the individual franchisee, and whether the franchise agreement lets someone step in if the operator fails. Victor contrasts this with McDonald’s, where long leases and the franchisor’s backing mean another operator typically steps in. What you are looking for, he says, is continuity of income.
Victor also warns about a more basic problem: the lease may not be in the name of the business actually operating. If someone has bought the business but the lease was never re-signed, the landlord may not have the legal right to enforce it. The investor should confirm who has actually signed the lease.
CHAPTER 05
Lease risk: The devil is in the detail
Because commercial value is tied to the income the lease produces, the lease is where much of the risk sits. Phil lists the main points to review: lease expiry, options, rent reviews, incentives, make-good clauses, outgoings and maintenance obligations. Victor’s emphasis is on the fine print behind each one.
Options and incentives. What happens at each option? Does the tenant get two weeks or a month rent-free? Does rent taper down towards the end of the lease as an inducement to stay? Features like these can quietly reduce the cash flow the investor thought they were buying.
Rent reviews. Is the rent fixed, such as a 4 per cent annual increase, or tied to CPI? Are there market reviews at each option?
Fit-out. Who owns it and who pays to refresh it? In some leases, the landlord returns part of the tenant’s fit-out cost on exit, as an incentive for the tenant to have done the work.
FROM THE SOURCE
The shop that had to be refitted every five years
Victor’s example is a shop for sale inside a small shopping centre. The centre’s rules require the fit-out to be renewed every five years, so the question for a buyer is who pays: the landlord or the tenant?
The answer sits in the lease and has to be part of due diligence. Phil’s point was that this is a very different playing field from residential. Someone has to pay to refresh what the shop looks like inside, and a buyer who has not checked may find out when the five years come around.
The lesson: A capital cost can be built into a centre’s rules, not just the lease. Ask who funds the refit, and when it is next due.
Make-good. Who pays to remove the tenant’s fit-out and return the space to a shell? The cost can be considerable, and the position can get murky. Phil says he always tries to negotiate no make-good clauses when he is a tenant. Victor adds that tenants sometimes do the maths and forgo their bond rather than make good, because making good would cost more. The investor should ask whether the fit-out left behind is an asset that helps re-let the property.
FROM THE SOURCE
‘It’s only in the asking’
Victor’s own office lease shows how flexible incentives can be. The fit-out in his current office did not suit him, so he asks the landlord for an incentive, since moving a few glass partitions would cost about $30,000. The landlord says yes.
“It’s only in the asking,” he says, adding that he has not yet moved the glass panels, three years on. Investors can use the same logic in reverse: if a tenant can negotiate an incentive for changes, the landlord should understand what the lease already promises.
Outgoings and the triple net lease. In a triple net lease, the tenant pays for the three major outgoings: land tax, property management and utilities. Victor warns the label is often bandied around unnecessarily. In Victoria, for example, land tax cannot necessarily be passed on, yet plenty of properties are advertised as triple net. His advice is to read the fine print rather than trust the advertisement. He also notes that stamp duty rules for commercial purchases vary by state. In the ACT and South Australia, for example, stamp duty may not apply to commercial purchases, with a few exceptions, and in regional areas there may be reductions for certain asset types. Investors should check the current position in each state.
Maintenance obligations. These must be documented. Larger logistics tenants will often do their own maintenance, but they are also better negotiators and may pay a lower rent per square metre. In every lease, Victor says, there is give and take.
CASE STUDY 3
The car park that belonged to the landlord
Some of the biggest costs appear only on a close reading of the lease.
THE DEAL
Right Property Group bought a large site in South Australia for a client. Three quarters of the block was car park, which offered the opportunity to expand the premises, and two businesses operated from the complex. Buried in the lease was the fact that maintenance of the car park was the landlord’s responsibility.
THE LESSON
Heavy rain and a few potholes become the owner’s expense. As Victor puts it, it is a risk that could only be assessed by going through the fine print of the lease.
Get the right solicitor
Both speakers insist on a lawyer who knows commercial leases. Victor says most people use the solicitor they have always used for residential and assume it is the same. “It’s like having a fracture and going to a massage therapist instead,” he says. Phil changes lawyers depending on the transaction and the state. Victor puts the cost of a lease review at anywhere from $2,500 to $15,000, depending on the complexity and the number of leases.
CHAPTER 06
Economic risk: The one you cannot control
Tenant risk and lease risk are, to a large degree, controllable. Economic risk is not. Commercial property is deeply tied to consumer spending, unemployment, business investment, population growth, business failures, the availability of credit and interest rates, and the investor can do little about any of them.
Phil describes the range of shocks. A black swan event is something like COVID-19 or the Global Financial Crisis, while a grey swan is something that has an impact but not as dramatic, such as changes to government tax rules. He says every business owner he speaks with at the moment says it is as hard as they have seen it, and sentiment is subdued despite what the government says. In a rising-rate environment, there is less money in family budgets, which means less spent in businesses.
Victor’s approach is to ask whether the business would survive a very big downturn. Would the tenant come back asking for rent relief, or simply fold? A hole-in-the-wall cafe might not be the right play, he says, depending on the risk the investor’s portfolio can carry. Childcare, he adds, is probably recession-proof, depending on location and government incentives.
FROM THE SOURCE
Even the defensive sector splits
Phil says he could not think of a business segment that is not finding it hard at the moment. Victor’s suggestion is that medical is probably the exception, particularly practices that bulk-bill, because people do not have much excess cash flow and a bulk-billed visit does not depend on it.
The picture is less clear for practices that do not bulk-bill all of their fees. Victor says psychologists, psychiatrists and similar practitioners he deals with are telling him business is slower.
The lesson: Medical may be more defensive than most sectors, but it is not one risk. Ask how the tenant gets paid and how exposed it is to household budgets before leaning on the sector’s reputation.
Both speakers recall the COVID-19 period when tenants asked landlords for rent relief. Phil’s landlord told him to provide financials and then “shut up”, an approach that shows how those negotiations can go.
A long lease is not necessarily a safe lease
One of Victor’s more counterintuitive points is that a long lease does not mean low risk. A struggling operator with a mediocre trading result on a long lease is quite likely to fold or ask for rent relief.
“A long lease does not necessarily mean less risk.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CASE STUDY 4
The $30k gift that lifted the loan
Sometimes the best way to reduce risk is to give something up.
THE DEAL
Victor describes a live case for clients. A tenant was in year seven of a 10-year lease, with a further 10-year option. Victor’s solution was to ask the tenant to exercise the option three years early, creating a 13-year lease instead of a 10-year one. In return, the tenant would not pay the consumer price index (CPI) increase in rent for the first two years. On that property, that meant $15,000 a year less, or $30,000 in total.
THE RESULT
The investor had effectively gifted $30,000 to the tenant, but had de-risked the investment. With a 13-year lease now executed, the lender was happy to lift the loan-to-value ratio from 70 to 75 per cent on a $6 million purchase.
THE LESSON
“Sometimes you need to think laterally to see how you can de-risk something,” Victor says. “When you take something, you’ve got to give something back.”
CHAPTER 07
Structural risk: When an industry changes
Structural risk is what happens when the business inside the building changes. Phil lists the main forces:
- Work from home and its effect on office demand.
- E-commerce and its effect on retail.
- Changes in logistics and warehousing.
- Automation, which Phil has stressed is not the same as AI: better systems and technology that remove people from manual work.
- The energy transition.
- Ageing populations, which affect healthcare demand.
The point from Part 2 still applies: it is not necessary to be obsessed with these forces, but investors need to be aware of them and ask how dependent the tenant’s business is on them.
The structure you buy in is a risk too
Victor adds a form of structural risk that he thinks deserves more attention: the entity that holds the property. Whether the asset sits in a trust, a company, personal names or a self-managed super fund has implications for how it is taxed, and the rules are not settled. He calls it a sovereign risk inherent in the government of the day.
Phil says there is still uncertainty about how family and discretionary trusts will be treated. The practical problem is that the structure chosen today is very hard to change. Moving an asset can be expensive and complicated, including the prospect of state stamp duty on transfers, that most owners do not try. If the long-term plan involves a generational exit, Phil says, investors may need to compensate for structural limits elsewhere.
CHAPTER 08
Property-specific risk: Buyer beware
The last category is the property itself. Phil lists the issues: building condition, contamination, zoning, access, parking, loading, compliance, fire and safety requirements and major capital expenditure. Each can be expensive, and the lease may or may not shift the cost to the tenant.
Building condition and insurance
Victor’s example is the asbestos roof, which is common in older industrial warehouses. It is an insurance risk. Some insurers will not insure such a building and others will charge a loaded premium. After a hailstorm, the roof generally has to be replaced, which is why insurers price in the extra risk. The investor should also check whether the lease contains a promise by the landlord to fix the roof or carry out other capital works.
Compliance: Split between landlord and tenant
Residential compliance is government-driven and increasingly onerous. Commercial compliance is more mixed. Victor says fire safety is shared between landlord and tenant. Trip hazards and general maintenance fall on the landlord, while industry-specific compliance falls on the tenant. His main point is to allow enough time for due diligence, which is why there is a due diligence period, similar to the cool-off period in residential.
Zoning and existing use rights
Zoning can cut both ways. A small pocket of commercial zoning in a sea of residential can have an upside, but changing zoning is very difficult. Victor warns of a related issue, existing use rights. Sometimes a business operates on a site where the zoning does not really permit it, but the council has taken a live-and-let-live approach for 10 or 20 years.
CASE STUDY 5
The mechanic’s garage that went back to being a house
A use that has always been tolerated may not survive a change of tenant.
THE DEAL
Victor’s example is a house that was turned into a mechanic’s garage. When the mechanic leaves, the property normally reverts to its actual zoning, which is residential. A new commercial tenant generally requires a development application, and the council is likely to push back, since the building ticks the box for residential supply.
THE LESSON
An investor buying on the strength of the current tenant needs to understand what rights attach to the use, and what happens if the tenant leaves.
Contamination: The big one
Both speakers single out contamination as one of the largest property risks. It can affect service stations, mechanics, timber yards, and any site with grease traps, fuel, oil or asbestos. Victor says remediation of fuel and oil contamination generally means at least a year of work before anything else can be done. Even if a petrol station replaces the current one, the site still has to be decontaminated before the next tenant moves in.
The costs flow on. Insurance can climb to the point where the property may not be insurable at all, which is a serious problem with members of the public coming on site.
CASE STUDY 6
2 years of testing
Contamination can turn a repurposing plan into a lengthy and expensive project.
THE DEAL
Phil recounts a friend who bought a half-finished project where someone had started to turn a former mechanic’s site into residential without approvals. Council approval was slow, and a major issue was contamination. Core holes had to be drilled, and the testing lasted for some two years. Remediation was an expense in itself.
THE LESSON
Repurposing commercial property to residential, or the other way round, can be fraught. Victor adds that a tenant may have already discovered contamination and pressed the current landlord to fix it, which could be the reason the owner is selling.
The disclosure rules add to the risk. A vendor is obliged to disclose contamination, Victor says, but only if asked. Commercial sales are a non-consumer sector with less protection, in the same way that an investor loan involves fewer questions than an owner-occupier loan. Victor says he has also bought a residential property in his own portfolio that was a former meth lab, knowing what the decontamination would cost and how long the process takes.
CHAPTER 09
When to walk away
Phil asks the obvious question: when does the risk become so large that you simply do not proceed? Victor’s answer is that with genuine contamination, such as a petrol station, he would want to walk away. More generally, it is when the risk outweighs the reward and when it could sink the portfolio, even if it would not sink someone else’s. That depends on operating costs, reserves and what he calls sleep-at-night factors.
There is a third test beyond risk and reward: will someone else buy it from you? An investor who buys something only because it is heavily discounted is looking at one end of the equation. Victor says every purchase needs an exit, and every portfolio needs exits at three levels:
- The debt exit: how the borrowings are reduced or repaid.
- The tax exit: planned with a financial planner and an accountant.
- The generational exit: how the portfolio is passed to the next generation.
“Any risk needs to have an exit, any purchase needs to have an exit, any portfolio needs to have an exit.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
The hidden risks of time and money
Phil also raises the cost of doing all this work. If an investor reviews 10 properties and buys none, the time and the fees are an expense. Victor’s estimate for a lease review alone is $2,500 to $15,000.
FROM THE SOURCE
100 properties to find 5
Due diligence in commercial property is a numbers game. Victor says a residential buyer might look at about 20 properties to choose five or six. In a commercial property, an investor might look at 100 to choose five.
Once a property is under contract, Right Property Group sends a list of 130 questions to the vendor’s agent, covering the risk factors. The answers produce a risk rating for the property and a recommendation: proceed or cut losses and move on. For the five that survive, the team adds another layer of diligence to make sure they are the cream of the crop and not the duds.
Phil asks whether the exercise is mostly about finding reasons not to buy. Victor’s answer is about the sifting: the work is in getting through a long list to a short one.
The lesson: Diligence has a real cost in time and fees, and most of it is spent on properties you will not buy. Build that cost into the plan and treat a “no” as a good outcome of the process.
CHAPTER 10
Risk inside a super fund
One place where the cost of capital looks different is a self-managed super fund. Phil notes that money in a super fund generally has not been borrowed against a home or drawn from an offset account. If the deposit and closing costs come from cash already in the fund, the primary loan is the only loan, and Victor says most properties bought that way would be neutral to positive.
CASE STUDY 7
The two-thirds rule for super
Victor’s guidance for a super fund is to keep it simple.
THE DEAL
The holding cost of a property in a fund is the shortfall between the rent and the loan repayments, which are likely to be principal and interest, plus the accounting and audit fees. Victor’s rule is that holding costs should not erode more than two-thirds of the member contributions going into the fund. Using Phil’s example, if $1,000 a month goes into super, up to $750 might go towards holding costs and $250 should stay in the fund as cash for a rainy day.
THE LESSON
A fund that never runs out of cash can ride out a vacancy. As Part 1 has argued, buying with almost every available dollar leaves no room for error. As always, the fund’s accountant should confirm the numbers.
CHAPTER 11
Investor checklist: Stress-testing the risks
Before committing, consider: (Tick each one you can answer with confidence.)
0 of 11
Anything unticked is worth working through before you buy. That’s a useful answer too.
And finally: is the yield enough to be paid for all of the risks above, or is it simply the biggest number on the page?