PART 4 • FINANCING COMMERCIAL PROPERTY
Financing commercial property: Debt, leverage and valuation
General information only. This report does not take into account your personal financial situation or needs. Speak to a licensed tax, legal, financial and credit professional before making any decision.
CHAPTER 01
Introduction
Parts 1 to 3 of this series have asked whether commercial property belongs in a portfolio, what to buy and where it goes wrong. Part 4 follows the money. How is a commercial property funded, and why does finance behave so differently from residential lending?
The question matters more now. With changes to self-managed super fund (SMSF) borrowing for residential property, there has been what the hosts describe as a flight towards commercial property. Many of the investors arriving have years of residential experience and may assume the lending works the same way. According to Right Property Group founder Victor Kumar, it largely does not.
While the concepts are the same as in residential, the way they operate is different, and investors who do not understand the differences can be caught out. Commercial finance, he says, carries a higher risk “especially in the later years of ownership of the property, not in the front end”.
This report, the fourth of six, draws on the experience of Phil Tarrant and Victor, covering how commercial loans are structured and sized, what the lender looks at, where the risk sits after settlement, and, in a dedicated segment, why SMSF investors are looking at commercial property in the post-August 2026 environment. Right Property Group has also produced a companion report on how a bank sizes a commercial loan and what cash an investor really needs.
“Residential lending revolves around your serviceability. Commercial revolves around the lease and the rent’s ability to pay down the loan.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CHAPTER 02
The big difference: Who is expected to pay the loan?
In residential lending, the borrower is assessed as the person who will pay down the debt. Everything revolves around serviceability and the borrower’s ability to make repayments, whether or not the property is leased.
In commercial lending, Victor says, the lender looks first to the lease. The rent, and the tenant paying it, is expected to service the loan. That is why so much of the value, and the finance, is contingent on the lease, the same lease that Part 1 and Part 3 have shown can create or destroy value.
The mechanics otherwise look familiar. The lender takes security over the property and may take other collateral, and the investor chooses between interest-only and principal and interest. Each lender also has its own criteria depending on the property type, the postcode and the purchase amount, just as in residential. Victor’s summary: the moving parts are mostly the same, but who is expected to make the repayment is different.
CHAPTER 03
Loan terms: One, three or five years
The second big differentiator is how long the loan runs. A residential loan of 25, 30 or even 40 years is not unusual. Commercial loans, Victor says, are often one, three or five years, with five usually the maximum unless the asset is unusual. Phil notes that commercial property held inside a super fund may be on more traditional 30-year terms without a lender returning each year to reprice.
Short terms mean the loan has to be renewed or refinanced at the end of each one, whatever the property is doing at the time. They also mean an annual review. Victor says this is what often trips up investors who are new to commercial property: the bank may ask for the latest rental receipts or the financials of the property or the entity, and the investor needs to be ready for the audit.
CASE STUDY 1
The act of kindness that triggered an LVR call
Victor describes how a small gesture can create a large problem at review time.
THE DEAL
In a market where business is down, a tenant approaches the landlord and asks for a reprieve on the rent. Out of the goodness of the landlord’s heart, the rent is reduced.
THE LESSON
A lower rent can lower the property’s value and so affect the loan-to-value ratio (LVR) when the bank reviews the loan. It can trigger what Victor calls a margin call, or LVR call. Investors who negotiate rent relief should understand what it does to the bank’s numbers first.
CHAPTER 04
Loan-to-value ratios: What you borrow depends on the lease
In general, Victor says, the larger the purchase price, the lower the loan-to-value ratio, unless the property has a very strong lease. A strong lease means a long term with many options to renew and a high-quality tenant. Phil’s example is an ASX 200 tenant, which a lender will view very differently from a small operator on a short lease.
Victor outlines three broad categories:
| Loan type | Typical LVR | What the lender relies on |
|---|---|---|
| Institutional and fund lending | As low as 40 per cent | Large assets such as shopping centres bought by investment funds |
| Lease doc | 50 to 70 per cent | The lease and the property, with minimal documentation |
| Full doc | 80 and even 90 per cent | The borrower’s full financial position, including residential lending |
A lease doc loan is the commercial equivalent of a residential low-doc or no-doc loan. Within the 50 to 70 per cent range, Victor says lenders differ widely. One may offer only 60 per cent on an asset while another is comfortable at 70 per cent, based on its outlook and niche in that kind of property. A full doc loan allows a higher LVR because the lender is looking at everything the borrower owns and spends.
“One lender may give you on the same asset only a 60 per cent loan to value ratio, whereas another lender would be quite comfortable giving you 70.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
What the deposit really looks like
Lower LVRs mean larger deposits. Victor’s example is a $1 million property on a lease doc loan, which would need about $400,000 to $450,000 in cash or accessible equity, depending on the LVR. Phil notes that lower LVRs are the reason commercial properties are often positively geared.
Victor urges caution on that point, which links back to Part 1. When a property is advertised as positive cash flow, it is often positive only because of the capital the investor has contributed. He says a residential property can do the same if the deposit is large enough. His example is a block of units with more than four dwellings on one title, which might get a 60 per cent LVR. With a 40 per cent deposit it would generally be positive, depending on the yield.
It is the same in commercial. The net yield determines whether a large deposit still produces a positive result, and Victor says it is not unusual to put in a huge deposit on a larger asset and still not be cash flow positive. Phil adds that if the capital is borrowed out of residential property, the debt levels are considerably higher and the picture changes.
CHAPTER 05
Serviceability: The interest cover ratio
In residential lending, Victor says, the rent cover ratio of 1.15 or 1.25 has been the yardstick. Rent covering 1.25 times the repayments, for example, has allowed some investors holding property in trusts and companies to access what he calls perpetual lending capacity.
Commercial lenders use an interest cover ratio, or ICR, and the required ratio varies from bank to bank. Victor gives the example of one lender at 1.3 and another at 1.2. For the same asset, the difference in ratio can change both sides of the equation: how much capital the investor has to contribute up front, and how much cash flow is left to hold the property. This is one reason the choice of lender matters as much as the choice of asset.
CHAPTER 06
Interest rates and costs: Everything is on steroids
Commercial interest rates are generally higher than residential, though, Victor says, not overly so. The difference is typically 0.5 percentage point to 1.5 percentage points. Everything is risk-weighted. If the property is in the sticks, or is very unusual, the lender will reduce the LVR and charge a premium on the rate too. Phil says some of his own commercial loans with a second-tier lender are well over 8 per cent.
Victor’s insights, echoed by Phil, are to keep rates in perspective. As in residential, the interest rate is often a third- or fourth-order consequence. The critical thing is being able to secure the debt.
Costs are a different matter. Victor says that in residential lending, the major banks tend to absorb the valuation fee. In commercial, the lender will always pass it on to the borrower.
FROM THE SOURCE
The $9,500 valuation
Second-tier residential lender
$220 to $500
Valuation fee
Victor’s commercial development
$9,500
Valuation fee
Victor is currently arranging finance for a commercial development in his own portfolio. The valuation fee came to $9,500. A second-tier residential lender, he says, might charge between $220 and $500.
The fee depends on factors such as how many tenants there are, where the property is, and how much research the valuer needs to do. It is also part of the reason finance conditions in commercial run longer. Before spending that kind of money, Victor says he wants to be sure the net yield being advertised is the net yield, with no surprises. Solicitor costs follow the same pattern. A commercial contract review can run to a couple of thousand dollars, compared with about $450 in residential.
“Everything’s on steroids in commercial in comparison to residential.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
CHAPTER 07
Interest-only or principal and interest?
The usual residential instinct is interest-only: borrow as much as possible, hope for growth and deal with the debt later. Victor says that is generally where commercial investors head too, particularly those who are income-focused and want sharper cash flow.
His own view is “50-50”. If holding the property is not costing an arm and a leg, he asks, why not pay down the principal? An investor who does so reaches unencumbered income, which means they are not subject to reviews or interest rate movements. He points to the medical centre discussed in an earlier episode, where the primary loan is paid out in 14 years. His reasoning is to take the pain at the front end, so that by the time the investor is at retirement age, when lending capacity also changes, they are still not carrying large debt.
CHAPTER 08
Valuation and due diligence: Where the numbers get tested
When a commercial property goes through contract, the lender’s valuer asks for a copy of the lease and goes through it with a fine-tooth comb to work out what is recoverable and what is not. That determines the real net yield, which sets the value.
CASE STUDY 2
The 5.5 per cent yield that valued at 4.5
Victor’s example shows how a lease can quietly change a valuation.
THE DEAL
A property is advertised at a 5.5 per cent net yield. The lease says the property management fee is recoverable, but in that state, the legislation may not allow it. Or the lease may be a retail lease, in which case certain costs cannot be clawed back. The valuer then calculates a net rent of 4.5 per cent and values the property accordingly.
THE LESSON
The lower valuation leaves a gap in the funding. That is why commercial contracts often include finance clauses of 30 or 60 days, against five or 10 days in residential, and why investors should do their own due diligence before spending money on a valuation.
If a valuation does not stack up after the contract is signed, can the price be renegotiated? Victor’s answer is yes and no. It depends on how negotiable the vendor is, and agents are sometimes not fully across the outgoings. That is where due diligence comes in.
CASE STUDY 3
The Milton strata deal with hidden landmines
Victor’s due diligence on a proposed purchase shows how a lender’s assessment can be derailed.
THE DEAL
Right Property Group was looking at a group of properties in Milton, on the NSW South Coast: a chiropractor, a doctor, a computer repair shop and one other tenant. The data room, essentially a shared online drive, and the agent both said there were only four strata units. Their due diligence found that the upstairs offices, owned by two financial planners, were also part of the strata, so the buyer would own most of the block but not all of it. Further due diligence found that the medical practice’s lease had been signed by the previous doctor, not the current one. The agent had not known because the vendor, which had three parties, had not supplied the right information.
THE LESSON
Had the deal gone ahead and been put under contract, Victor says, the valuer would have found the same problems and the proposition to the lender would have changed substantially. When presenting a business case to a lender, make sure there are no landmines in it. They can derail the whole thing.
A related measure is the weighted average lease expiry, or WALE. Victor likens it to a block of units where some leases have just renewed and others are about to expire. A longer WALE generally makes lenders more comfortable, provided the leases are at market, because it supports the income the lender is relying on to meet the repayments.
CHAPTER 09
Lenders: Who they are, what they want and how fast they can change their minds
Different lender categories
Victor says the big four banks all have commercial arms. There are also specialist lenders who look at out-of-the-box scenarios. As in residential, where a single dwelling can go to almost any lender but a duplex, a triplex or a block of four narrows the field, commercial lending narrows with complexity, and with the dollar value as well as the number of tenants. Phil adds that more specialised assets such as storage have more specialised lenders, and investors can find themselves dealing with companies they have never heard of.
Some specialists focus on a single sector, such as medical or childcare. Victor says they understand the business and may offer a sharper rate or a higher LVR than other lenders.
Lender appetite can change midway
The flip side is that lender appetite can shift during the life of the loan. Victor says a lender may decide it no longer likes childcare centres and cut the LVR. He gave office as another example: an investor who bought in the heyday could find that, after a review, the lender will not renew the loan after the three-year term and tells them to find someone else.
“Finance is one of the biggest risks in commercial, mainly because you’re so reliant on the lease to perform and so reliant on the lender’s appetite.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
Guarantees and documentation
Even on a lease doc loan, Victor says the lender ultimately wants a person behind it. That is usually a personal guarantee, and sometimes a business guarantee or a fixed and floating charge over business income, depending on the exposure and the LVR. The one time an investor is unlikely to give a personal guarantee is when buying through a super fund.
On a full doc loan, Phil and Victor note that the lender typically takes a charge over the borrower’s present and future assets, along with directors’ guarantees, and will pursue other assets if the borrower defaults.
The documentation reflects the same split:
- Lease doc: the contract, the repayment history and the usual identity and anti-money-laundering checks. It is the smallest set of documents, but still substantial.
- Full doc: open books. The lender goes through the borrower’s residential lending and expenditure and tests whether the repayments can be met if the tenant is not there.
- Reviews: rental statements and, in larger cases, access to the tenant for an interview.
Victor’s summary is that the principle stays the same as in residential: all the bank is trying to do is make sure the borrower can make the repayments.
CHAPTER 10
Refinancing and structuring: Slow, siloed and clunky
Structuring is more important in commercial than in residential, Victor says, because resetting a commercial loan takes much longer. An investor with 10 residential properties might restructure in a month or two. In commercial, workshopping the right fit can take a couple of months, which is why the market hears less about refinancing within commercial portfolios. Phil describes it as stovepiped: lease doc loans are siloed against each asset, which keeps the risk contained but requires more capital because the LVRs are lower.
Commercial purchases funded by residential equity add another layer. Residential lenders do not typically like equity being used to buy commercial property, and some investors may not be able to extract the equity at all, which may be why they are looking at commercial in the first place.
CASE STUDY 4
The hybrid loan that got clunky
Some commercial lenders will work around this, with a trade-off.
THE DEAL
Victor says he arranged for a commercial lender to take on one of his residential properties, a block of four, which the lender could treat as a commercial property, and the lender lent him money for the commercial purchase.
THE LESSON
The structure puts part of the residential portfolio with a commercial lender, which is a clunky arrangement. If the investor later wants to sell the residential property, the commercial side has to be revalued to remain with the existing lender or move to a new one. If market sentiment has changed, as it has in office, the investor can be forced to contribute more equity.
CHAPTER 11
Finance risk: What happens if...
The conversation returned repeatedly to the same set of scenarios. Together, they show how the risks interact.
- The valuation falls. New supply, a lower per-square-metre rate or a lease that turns out to have fewer recoverable outgoings can reduce the value. That narrows the gap between the loan and the property and can mean new capital is needed at purchase or at review.
- Lender policy changes. A lender can change policy mid-term, for example by cutting LVRs for a sector or declining to renew loans on an asset class.
- LVR requirements change. Whether through policy or a lower valuation, a higher required ratio means the investor must find more equity. This is the same mechanism as the LVR call that follows an unrecorded rent reduction.
- The loan matures. With terms of one, three or five years, the loan must be renewed or refinanced regularly. The investor cannot assume the lender will do so on the same terms, or at all.
- The property becomes vacant. Victor and Phil agree that this is the biggest risk for commercial investors and the source of the horror stories. Rent is the basis of the loan, and without it the investor must carry the repayments and the lender’s confidence erodes. Because lenders are also less likely to lend against a vacant property, it is harder to raise money to fix the problem.
- Interest rates rise. Phil notes that this is a risk the investor can do little about, so buffers matter, as in residential.
The common thread is the six-to-12-month reserve from Part 1. Finance risk does not arrive in the early years. It arrives at the review, the renewal and the vacancy, and the investor needs the capital to survive each one.
CHAPTER 12
SMSF: Commercial property in the post-August 2026 environment
What has changed
Since 10 August 2026, new limited recourse borrowing arrangements (LRBA) used by an SMSF to buy property have generally been restricted to business real estate. Residential property can no longer be bought with an LRBA, although a fund may still buy it outright using its own money. Existing arrangements are treated differently. Existing LRBAs entered into before that date, and the refinancing of those arrangements, are generally grandfathered, as are binding contracts to acquire real property that were exchanged before the date. Transitional situations can be technical, so trustees should obtain advice on their own circumstances.
Why commercial is getting the attention
Phil’s observation is that many people set up super funds specifically to invest in property. When residential borrowing was removed, many of them turned to commercial. He believes there has been a huge increase in this and that “there’ll be in the future a lot of attention placed on poor decisioning” around buying commercial property inside a super fund.
There is also a long-standing logic. Phil says accountants have often advised buying the premises used for the investor’s own business inside the super fund, with the business paying the rent. There is, he says, “a little bit more integrity around it”.
Liquidity: The six-month rule
Victor’s strongest warning concerns liquidity. Using funds from the super account means there is no deposit or closing cost financed with other debt, and, as Part 3 notes, properties bought this way are often neutral to positive. But the fund can still run out of cash.
CASE STUDY 5
The $50,000 that was supposed to last
Victor says the higher risk sits on the SMSF side of commercial lending.
THE DEAL
A fund buys a $1 million warehouse with $600,000 of cash. After every cost is taken into account, including the lender’s requirements and the location, only $50,000 remains. The property then sits vacant for a year, which can happen in commercial, particularly if the investor is chasing yield.
THE LESSON
Once the $50,000 is gone, the fund has to find the holding costs for the rest of the year. Extra contributions have a knock-on tax impact, and some members will not be in a position to make them. They may have maxed out their contributions or stopped accumulating because of their age.
Victor’s rule: investors should not buy commercial property in an SMSF unless they have six full months of repayments left over after the transaction and still have contributions coming in. Otherwise, the question is whether the fund should hold the property at all.
“Unless you’ve got six full months of repayment left over after the transaction and you’ve still got contributions coming in as well, you shouldn’t be really doing this.”
– VICTOR KUMAR, RIGHT PROPERTY GROUP
Concentration risk and cash flow
A fund with a small balance and one large property has most of its money in a single asset, with a single tenant and no way to sell down part of it. Phil observes that the assets bought at lower balances often have very transitional tenants, which adds risk. Victor’s example of a fund with around $200,000 is that the investor can still buy a commercial property, but the question is whether it is worth buying.
For investors who are not sure, Victor suggests going back to the financial plan and asking whether an SMSF is needed at all. Winding it back has a cost, but may be the sane move, as may shifting to equities. Phil notes that commercial exposure is also available through listed real estate investment trusts inside super.
A second boundary applies to advisers. Victor says buyers’ agents and property strategists who advise setting up a self-managed super fund to buy property are straying out of their space, and that advice on the super fund itself needs to come from an accountant and a financial planner.
CHAPTER 13
Broker and process: The practical steps
To avoid risk and ensure that the right investment vehicles are being used, investors should use a specialist commercial broker. A residential broker is not a substitute, in the same way that a broker who specialises in first home buyers is not the right person for an investor with several properties.
Victor’s preferred sequence has three steps:
01
Work out your borrowing capacity, but not necessarily a formal pre-approval, because you do not yet know the asset, postcode or loan-to-value ratio.
02
When you find a property, give the broker the high-level attributes: purchase price, rate per square metre or lease, and the strength of the tenant. The broker can run it past the lending team for an indication of appetite.
03
Only then sign a contract. Signing first means the solicitor review is paid for, at a couple of thousand dollars, even if the deal falls over.
Phil adds that pre-approvals are less useful in commercial because the assets are so spread out. A pre-approval for $500,000 in Ballarat might be comfortable in Bendigo, but commercial lenders may see each property differently.
CHAPTER 14
Investor checklist: Are you ready to fund it?
Before committing to a commercial loan, consider: (Tick each one you can answer with confidence.)
0 of 11
Anything unticked is worth working through before you buy. That’s a useful answer too.
And finally: could you survive a review, a valuation and a vacancy in the same year?
COMPANION REPORT • PART 4
Positive From Day One?
How the bank sizes a commercial loan, what cash you really need, and the risks that can change the numbers.
INSIDE THE REPORT
01
The ICR test
How much will the bank lend?
02
The day-one check
Positive from day one? Count the deposit.
03
When the bank turns
Six things that change the numbers
+
Your day-one calculator
Check any property before you offer
PDF · 4 pages · 147 KB
Companion report to Episode 4 of The Post-Budget Guide to Commercial Property Investing, with Phil Tarrant (Smart Property Investment) and Victor Kumar (Right Property Group).