While everyone is losing their heads, keep yours
As changes to negative gearing and CGT pass the Senate, Phillip Tarrant urges property professionals and investors to not confuse disruption with destruction
There are moments in markets when the noise gets so loud that people forget to think.
This is one of those moments.
Australia’s property investment ecosystem has just been ploughed up. Negative gearing settings are changing. Capital gains tax settings are changing. SMSF lending into residential property has been hit. The federal budget has turned into a major reset for property investors, advisers, brokers, accountants, lenders and every business that sits around the property investment advice sector.
And right now, there’s a lot of uncertainly out there.
Buyer’s agents are worried their pipeline will slow because negative gearing on established property is changing, and SMSF lending has been curtailed. Brokers are wondering what happens as investor appetite potentially pulls back and SMSF lending work dries up. Lenders that built strong books around SMSF residential as well as investor lending are trying to work out where the next pocket of growth comes from. Accountants who advise heavily in SMSF structures are recalibrating. Property investors are asking whether the rules have changed so much that they should sit on their hands.
My view is simple.
While everyone is losing their heads, keep yours.
This is not the time for panic. It is not the time for outrage for the sake of outrage. And it is definitely not the time for property professionals to disappear into doom and gloom.
This is the time for leadership.
Because when the ground around you gets ploughed up, that is when you put seeds down.
The property investment advice sector needs to see this moment for what it is. Yes, it is disruptive. Yes, it will change behaviour. Yes, some business models will come under pressure. But it is also a reset. And resets create opportunity for the people who are calm enough, smart enough and client-focused enough to adapt.
The need for a reset
Let’s be honest. Some parts of the property investment industry have had it too easy for too long.
For years, too much of the conversation has centred on tax outcomes rather than investment outcomes. Too much advice has been built around what someone can deduct, rather than what they are actually buying, why they are buying it, how they will hold it, and what it does inside their broader wealth strategy.
That era is changing.
And that is not necessarily a bad thing.
Good investors do not buy property just because of negative gearing. Good investors do not build wealth because a tax setting does the heavy lifting for them. Good investors buy quality assets, with sensible debt, strong cash flow management, a clear strategy, a long-term view and the discipline to hold through cycles.
The same goes for good advisers.
Good buyer’s agents are not order takers or marketers. They are strategists. They help clients understand markets, risk, location, asset quality, supply, demand, rental depth and exit strategy. If a buyer’s agent’s entire business model only worked because an investor could negatively gear an established property, or use some complicated tax structure, then the problem was not the legislation. The problem was the business model.
Good brokers are not just loan processors. They are debt strategists. If SMSF lending erodes, yes, that will hurt some parts of the market. But investors will still need funding advice. First home buyers will still need help. Upgraders will still need help. Business owners will still need help. Investors will still need help restructuring, refinancing, managing buffers and understanding borrowing capacity in a changed environment.
Good accountants are not just compliance machines. They are trusted advisers. SMSF property work may change, but the need for tax planning, structuring, cash flow advice, asset protection, succession planning and business advisory will not disappear. In fact, in a more complex environment, that advice becomes more valuable.
And lenders should be thinking the same way. If one channel closes or narrows, the smart operators do not sit around complaining about yesterday’s market. They find the next one. They sharpen their proposition. They support brokers with clarity. They build products that match the new reality.
That is what leadership looks like.
A window opens for disciplined investors
For investors, this may also be one of the most interesting periods we have seen in years.
Why?
Because fear creates space.
When people get spooked, they pause. When headlines get ugly, they hesitate. When policy changes land, a lot of investors retreat to the sidelines because they cannot separate noise from opportunity.
That can create a window for serious investors.
If there is less competition from investors, then the people who are still prepared, still financed, still strategic and still willing to do the work may find themselves in a stronger position. They may face less heat at auction. They may get more time to make decisions. They may be able to negotiate better. They may be able to buy assets that others are too nervous to pursue.
But that only applies to investors who know what they are doing.
This is not a call to rush in blindly. Quite the opposite.
This is a call to get sharper.
Investors need to revisit their strategy. They need to understand what these changes mean for their personal position. They need to speak with their accountant, broker, financial adviser and property adviser. They need to model the numbers properly. They need to look at cash flow before tax, after tax, at today’s interest rates and at higher rates. They need to understand land tax, insurance, maintenance, vacancy risk and liquidity.
In other words, they need to behave like investors.
Not speculators. Not headline chasers. Not people looking for a tax deduction with a property attached to it.\
Real investors.
The property investment advice sector has a responsibility here. This is not a moment to scare people into action. It is not a moment to use fear as a marketing funnel. It is not a moment to tell everyone that the sky is falling so they book a call.
It is a moment to educate.
Explain what has changed. Explain what has not changed. Explain who is impacted. Explain who is not. Explain where the risks are. Explain where the opportunities may be. Explain that property investment has never been a one-size-fits-all game, and it certainly is not one now.
The advisers who do that well will build trust.
The advisers who run around screaming will burn it.
The simple truth is this: Australia still needs private investment in housing. Renters still need quality homes. Investors still need long-term wealth-building options. The housing shortage has not disappeared because the tax rules have changed. Population growth has not disappeared. The need for good advice has not disappeared.
What has disappeared is the luxury of lazy strategy.
And that is why I am optimistic.
I am optimistic because disruption forces better thinking. It forces better advice. It forces better asset selection. It forces investors to understand their numbers. It forces businesses to sharpen their value proposition. It forces the whole sector to become more professional.
That is good for investors.
That is good for clients.
And in the long run, it is good for the property investment advice industry.
So to the buyer’s agents, brokers, accountants, lenders, advisers and property professionals who are feeling anxious right now: take a breath.
Do not confuse disruption with destruction.
Do not confuse policy change with the end of opportunity.
Do not confuse fear in the market with the absence of demand.
Your clients need you. They need calm heads. They need clear thinking. They need people who can look past the headline and explain what to do next.
And to Australian investors: do not let the panic of the crowd become your investment strategy.
Review your position. Get advice. Understand the rules. Stress-test your numbers. Be patient. Be selective. Be disciplined.
The market has been ploughed up.
Now it is time to plant for the next cycle.
While everyone else is losing their heads, keep yours.
Phillip Tarrant is CEO of Managed , a podcast host, investor and property commentator. Follow him on LinkedIn.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Smart Property Investment a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Smart Property Investment as a preferred news source.