Falling markets or falling investor demand: What came first?

By Sasha Karen 31 July 2018 | 1 minute read

You don’t have to go far to hear about how Sydney and Melbourne are experiencing a softening in the market and the number of investors in Australia are declining, but which one is responsible for the other? CoreLogic explores this by taking a look at mortgage commitments.

Chicken and egg, what came first, falling markets or falling investor

Growth in investor lending is at an all-time low, according to CoreLogic research analyst Cameron Kusher, due to tightened credit policies targeting investors more so than owner-occupiers, as well as a number of investors switching over from interest-only to principal and interest loans.

Owner occupier loans excluding, and then including refinances both saw rises, which are at $14.9 billion and $6.3 billion respectively, but investor loans are down to $10.7 billion: the only category to record a decline, down by 27.5 per cent compared to their peak from April 2015.

“As a result the principal is now being repaid and outstanding credit is reducing whereas in the past there was no reduction of the principal,” Mr Kusher said.

Therefore, the CoreLogic research analyst claimed that investors are experiencing a credit crunch for investors, while owner-occupiers are avoiding a credit crunch of their own.


Another factor for the investor lending environment has been the previous activity in Sydney and Melbourne in comparison to how it is currently, coupled with the lack of significant growth elsewhere.

“What is unknown is whether it is market conditions that have led to the fall in in investor demand or is it the fall in investor demand that has led to the decline in values; in reality it is probably a combination of both,” Mr Kusher said.

Comparatively, owner-occupiers make up 66.5 per cent of all loans, according to Mr Kusher, and demand for owner-occupier loans is stable.

However, as investors make up the minority share of all mortgage lending, and with the continued expectation of the softening of the Sydney and Melbourne markets and the oversupply in these cities, Mr Kusher states the impact of a credit crunch for investors is less than if a crunch were to happen for owner-occupiers.

Looking to the future, Mr Kusher predicted housing finance commitments overall to slow down.

“Given this, the overall value of housing finance commitments is anticipated to fall and the expansion in housing credit will likely continue to slow.”



Interest is the amount of money charged by a lender or financial institution for a loan, which is calculated as the percentage of the principal amount paid over the loan term.

About the author

Falling markets or falling investor demand: What came first?
Chicken and egg, what came first, falling markets or falling investor
spi logo

Get the latest news & updates

Join a community of over 100,000 property investors.

Check this box to receive podcast updates

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.